Dairy

Filters

Collections

Amish Butter Roll

Regular price $8.99
Sale price $8.99 Regular price
Unit price

Eggs- PICK UP ONLY

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Unit price

String Cheese

Regular price $9.99
Sale price $9.99 Regular price
Unit price

Muenster Cheese

Regular price $13.99
Sale price $13.99 Regular price
Unit price

Cheddar, White Extra Sharp Cheese

Regular price $13.99
Sale price $13.99 Regular price
Unit price

Mozzarella Cheese

Regular price $13.99
Sale price $13.99 Regular price
Unit price

Cheddar, White Medium Cheese

Regular price $13.99
Sale price $13.99 Regular price
Unit price

Marble Cheese

Regular price $11.99
Sale price $11.99 Regular price
Unit price

Michigan Jack Cheese

Regular price $11.99
Sale price $11.99 Regular price
Unit price

Cheddar, White Sharp Cheese

Regular price $13.99
Sale price $13.99 Regular price
Unit price

Colby Cheese

Regular price $11.99
Sale price $11.99 Regular price
Unit price

Smoked Cheddar Cheese

Regular price $14.99
Sale price $14.99 Regular price
Unit price

Baby Swiss Cheese

Regular price $15.99
Sale price $15.99 Regular price
Unit price

Onion & Garlic Cheese

Regular price $11.99
Sale price $11.99 Regular price
Unit price

Pinconning Mild Cheddar Cheese

Regular price $11.99
Sale price $11.99 Regular price
Unit price

Hot Pepper Cheese

Regular price $11.99
Sale price $11.99 Regular price
Unit price

Horseradish Cheese

Regular price $12.99
Sale price $12.99 Regular price
Unit price

Dill Cheese

Regular price $11.99
Sale price $11.99 Regular price
Unit price

Habanero Cheese

Regular price $11.99
Sale price $11.99 Regular price
Unit price

Pinconning Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Regular price $13.99
Sale price $13.99 Regular price
Unit price

Pinconning Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Regular price $12.99
Sale price $12.99 Regular price
Unit price

Provolone Cheese

Regular price $12.99
Sale price $12.99 Regular price
Unit price
Sort by
  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old