Pinconning Extra Sharp Cheddar

Pinconning Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(0) | Write a review

Pinconning cheddar from grass fed dairy cows.

Price:	11.99
Pre order amount:	$ 6.00

base price : $ 15.99 per 1 lb

Add to cart

Buy Now

Approximately 0.75 lb per package. The advertised price is an estimate and based on exactly 0.75 lbs. The exact price will vary based on the actual weight of your package.

Add to Wishlist

Questions?

Email a friend

What You're Getting

Pinconning is a Colby-style cheddar cheese that is semi-hard and will age quite well, developing mild-strong flavor.

Ingredients: Pasteurized milk, salt, cheese culture, enzymes, annatto (color)

Helpful Hints & Cooking Tricks

Learn more about our Grass Fed Cheese and Dairy products on our blog!

Farming Practices

John Henry's is proud to offer Farm Country Cheese House Products. Farm Country Cheese House broke ground in April, 1983 and began production in July of 1984. From the beginning, the Amish communities in and around Lakeview, Michigan have supplied all of the milk and most of the labor to process the wide variety of cheeses sold. The Amish Farmers' average herd size is up to 20 cows. The cows are naturally raised, grass fed and antibiotic free, with absolutely no artificial hormones introduced in their diet. The farmers milk the cows twice daily, by hand, for delivery to the Cheese House.

Customers who bought this item also bought

Chicken Chorizo Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. Our Chicken Chorizo Brats are made with Pasture Raised Chicken and seasoned with a certified organic seasoning. Try something different!

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Chicken Chorizo Breakfast Links, 12/pk

Add a little spice to your breakfast and try our new Chicken Chorizo Breakfast Sausage Links! Each 1 lb package will contain about 12 links.

$ 9.99

Add to Cart

Dairy Free Chicken Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. You'll receive an approximately 1 lb package containing 4 quarter pound brats. This is a DAIRY FREE version of our regular chicken bratwurst.

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Pork Steaks, 2/pk

These well-marbled Pork Steaks are easy to cook, and delicious!

$ 17.48

Add to Cart

Turkey Burger Patties 2/pk

These juicy Turkey Burgers are made with our exclusive Ground Turkey blend of dark and light meat together. These are not your average Turkey Burgers! You'll receive 2 patties per package.

10% off $ 6.70 $ 6.03

Add to Cart

Plain Chevre Goat Cheese

This creamy, spreadable Chevre has many uses and is so delicious! You'll receive an 8 oz container of goat cheese.

$ 8.50

Add to Cart

Eggs - Pickup ONLY

1 dz Farm Fresh Eggs. ONLY AVAILABLE FOR MARKET OR LOCAL PICK UP.

$ 5.00

Add to Cart

Corned Beef Brisket, Pre-Seasoned

Our grass-fed brisket has been trimmed and pre-seasoned for you!

46% off $ 48.39 $ 25.97

Add to Cart

Thin Sliced from Bnls/Skls Chicken Breast 1 lb.

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.

$ 7.89

Add to Cart

Bacon Burger - Bulk 1 lb.

Try our best selling blend of Ground Sirloin and our Hickory Smoked Bacon!

$ 11.99

Add to Cart

Ground Round, 1 lb

This 85/15 blend of Ground Round has a medium fat content with lots of flavor! You'll receive approximately 1 lb of ground meat per package.

$ 10.99

Add to Cart

Ground Sirloin, 1 lb

Our leanest Grass Fed Ground Beef blend has all the flavor without the fat! You'll receive approximately 1 lb of ground meat per package.

$ 11.99

Add to Cart

Bacon Burger Patties (2/pk)

WARNING: Bacon Burgers are extremely delicious and irresistible. The smokey bacon adds a unique flavor to these 1/3 lb preformed square patties. These are a must try!

10% off $ 9.99 $ 8.99

Add to Cart

English Roast - Bone In

Great for braising or roasting! Our butcher cuts the English Roast between 2.0 - 3.5 lbs.

$ 32.97

Add to Cart

Rolled Rump Roast

Outstanding flavor and tenderness when slow cooked! Our butcher cuts these roasts at approximately 2 - 3.5 lbs.

$ 29.97

Add to Cart

Sirloin Tip Roast

A very lean cut from the bottom sirloin. Our butcher cuts the Sirloin Tip Roast at approximately 2 - 3.5 lbs.

$ 32.97

Add to Cart

Fajita Meat from Beef Sirloin

Fajitas have never been easier, our butcher does the work for you! Just open the package, add seasonings, and start cooking!

$ 11.99

Add to Cart

Shaved Sizzle Steak

This thinly sliced steak meat is cut from the flavorful Sirloin and cooks up quickly. Great for weeknight meals!

$ 11.99

Add to Cart

Stew Meat

Our stew meat is cut from the lean and juicy beef sirloin into perfect bite size pieces that are ready for your next pot of soup or stew!

$ 10.99

Add to Cart

Flank Steak

This thin, lean steak is already scored and ready for your favorite marinade or seasoning rub! Each Flank Steak is about 2-3 servings of meat, or 1.5-2 lbs each.

$ 29.99

Add to Cart

Sirloin Steak

These long, flavorful steaks are cut at 3/4 inch thickness.

$ 23.99

Add to Cart

T-Bone Steak

These massive grass-fed T-Bone Steaks are cut at 1 inch thickness and weigh about 1lb each.

$ 27.99

Add to Cart

Beef Liver - Sliced

This superfood is packed full of nutrients, minerals and vitamins! Our butcher slices the Beef Liver into 3/8" pieces. There will be approximately 3-5 slices in a 1 lb package.

$ 5.69

Add to Cart

Beef Short Ribs

Our Beef Short Ribs are cut from the lower belly "plate" section of ribs. Our butcher trims and separates them into a nice individual size, perfect for everyday cooking!

$ 19.49

Add to Cart

Suet

Use grass-fed Suet for pie crusts, pastries and more! You'll receive a 1 lb package of fresh, un-rendered suet per package.

$ 2.39

Add to Cart

Canadian Style Bacon

Our Canadian bacon is cut from the loin section of the pastured pig then fully smoked. We offer it sliced in 1/2 lb packages so it is ready to eat!

$ 5.50

Add to Cart

Hickory Smoked Bacon

Our bacon is hickory smoked without the use of nitrates! Hickory Smoked Bacon comes in a 1 lb package.

$ 10.99

Add to Cart

Peppercorn Bacon

Cured and seasoned with Peppercorn for a bold kick of flavor! Peppercorn Bacon is available in a 1 lb package.

$ 10.99

Add to Cart

Pork Butt / Shoulder

This marbled Pork Butt or Pork Shoulder Roast is perfect for slow cooking or smoking. Our butcher cuts each Pork Butt at about 3 lbs. You'll receive 1 roast per package.

$ 26.97

Add to Cart

Pork Chops - Boneless, 2/pk

A perfect pair of pastured pork chops, removed from the bone and ready for your meal!

$ 9.49

Add to Cart

Pork Loin Roast, Rolled - Netted

This Pork Loin Roast has been trimmed, rolled and netted for a lovely presentation.

$ 23.23

Add to Cart

Pork Tenderloin

This cut of meat is all tenderness and a huge customer favorite!

$ 12.59

Add to Cart

Baby Back Ribs

These short and meaty ribs are perfect for your next barbeque!

$ 32.97

Add to Cart

Country Style Ribs 4/pk

All meat, no bones. These Country Style Ribs are perfect for those who prefer to eat their BBQ Ribs with a fork rather than their hands!

$ 14.99

Add to Cart

Pork Breakfast Sausage, 1 lb

Our Dairy Free Pork Breakfast Sausage is a cut above the rest! This grind will arrive in 1 lb packages.

$ 9.49

Add to Cart

Pork Italian Sausage, 1 lb

Our popular ground Italian Sausage adds a nice flavor to your favorite dishes!

$ 9.49

Add to Cart

Pork Chorizo Sausage, 1 lb

Our Ground Chorizo Sausage is ready to spice up breakfast!

$ 9.49

Add to Cart

Ground Pork, 1 lb

Our Ground Pork is freshly ground in small batches from the loin of our pastured pigs. No fillers, just good clean pork!

$ 8.99

Add to Cart

Pork Breakfast Sausage Links, 12/pk

Our Dairy Free Pork Breakfast Sausage Links are a family favorite! You'll receive 12 breakfast links in a 1 lb package.

$ 9.69

Add to Cart

Maple Breakfast Sausage Links, 12/pk

Our Dairy Free Maple Pork Breakfast Links are addictive! You'll receive 12 breakfast links in a 1 lb package.

$ 9.69

Add to Cart

Polish Sausage - Fresh, 2/pk

Our Fresh Polish Sausage, or traditional Kielbasa, is made with our pasture-raised Ground Pork, blended with a perfect mix of spices, and packed in fresh casings. Each package of polish sausage contains 2 - 10" unsmoked sausage links.

$ 11.04

Add to Cart

Pork Polish Sausage - Smoked, 2/pk

Our Smoked Polish Sausage, or traditional Kielbasa, is made with our pasture-raised Ground Pork, blended with a perfect mix of spices, packed in casings, then smoked for incredible flavor. Each package of polish sausage contains 2 - 10" smoked sausage links.

$ 9.74

Add to Cart

Ham, Bone In - Smoked

Our Old Fashioned Bone-In Hickory Smoked Hams can be cut to desired weight from 5-15 lbs. Includes a Recipe Card!

$ 41.45

Add to Cart

Cheesy Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. You'll receive an approximately 1 lb package containing 4 quarter pound brats.

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Italian Pork Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. You'll receive an approximately 1 lb package containing 4 quarter pound brats.

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Italian Turkey Bratwurst

Made with our pasture-raised Ground Turkey blend, these quarter pound bratwursts are homemade!

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Jalapeno Cheese Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. You'll receive an approximately 1 lb package containing 4 quarter pound brats.

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Regular Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. You'll receive an approximately 1 lb package containing 4 quarter pound brats.

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Ground Turkey-Dark Meat, 1 lb

This blend of Ground Turkey is made exclusively with dark meat from our pastured turkeys and is available in 1 lb packages.

$ 8.99

Add to Cart

Turkey Breakfast Sausage Links, 12/pk

Try our best-selling, mild Turkey Breakfast Sausage in links! You'll receive 12 breakfast links in a 1 lb package.

$ 9.99

Add to Cart

Turkey Breast, Bone In - Half

Our Bone-In, Pasture-Raised Turkey Breasts are scrumptious and moist! Each split turkey breast averages about 2-3 lbs.

$ 19.98

Add to Cart

Hard Salami - Deli Sliced

Cut to order! Our uniquely flavored, deli sliced Salami is available thin, medium or thick cut.

$ 11.89

Add to Cart

Smoked Turkey Breast - Deli Sliced

Our delicious smoked turkey lunchmeat can be cut to order!

$ 16.89

Add to Cart

Bnls/Skls Chicken Breast, 2/pk

Receive 2 of our pasture raised boneless and skinless Chicken Breasts.

10% off $ 19.23 $ 17.31

Add to Cart

Bnls/Skls Chicken Breast, 10 lb bag

This bulk order option includes 10lbs of our Boneless Skinless Chicken Breasts in a single 10lb bag.

$ 108.90

Add to Cart

Chicken Thighs, Bone In, 4/pk

Cut from our smaller pasture raised chickens, these Bone In Chicken Thighs are perfectly portioned.

$ 13.28

Add to Cart

Chicken Thighs, Boneless Skinless, 4/pk

These tender thighs from pasture raised chickens have had the bones, skin and fat removed.

$ 13.98

Add to Cart

Bone in Chicken Breast 2/pk

Our split breasts are left on the bone with the skin on.

$ 7.99

Add to Cart

Chicken Drumsticks 4/pk

These drumsticks from our pasture raised chickens are the perfect serving size.

$ 11.24

Add to Cart

Ground Chicken, 1 lb

This high-quality ground meat from our Pasture-Raised, Free Range chickens is not like any ground chicken you've ever had before!

$ 8.99

Add to Cart

Chicken Tenders

Our Chicken Tenders are sliced from the inner rib section of the breast meat from our pasture raised chickens.

$ 11.29

Add to Cart

Tenderized Chicken Breast, 2/pk

Our butchers will butterfly the chicken breast and tenderize it for you!

$ 14.11

Add to Cart

Thin Sliced Chicken Breast

Thin slices of trimmed Boneless/Skinless Chicken Breast that are the perfect size for stir fry! Available in 1 lb packages.

$ 11.29

Add to Cart

Fryer Chicken - Whole

These smaller birds are very lean and average 3-5lbs.

$ 18.23

Add to Cart

Beef Jerky - Plain

Our Beef Fajita strips are seasoned and smoked for a delicious snack! No MSG!

$ 7.99

Add to Cart

Sweet Beef Jerky

Our sweet beef jerky contains no MSG!

$ 7.99

Add to Cart

Cheesy Jalapeno Snack Sticks

These MSG free snack sticks pack a spicy little punch, just enough to be delicious!

$ 5.99

Add to Cart

Ground Chuck, 1 lb

A juicy 81/19 blend of Grass Fed Ground Chuck makes the best burgers! You'll receive approximately 1 lb of ground meat per package.

$ 9.99

Add to Cart

Michigan Jack Cheese

Our Michigan Jack is from Farm Country Cheese House in Lakeview, MI.

$ 9.49

Add to Cart

Marble Cheese

Delightful combination of Colby and Michigan Jack from Farm Country Cheese House.

$ 9.69

Add to Cart

Provolone Cheese

Provolone from Farm Country Cheese House in Lakeview, MI.

$ 10.99

Add to Cart

Dill Cheese

Creamy Michigan Jack cheese from grass fed, hand milked cows with fresh farm grown dill.

$ 9.59

Add to Cart

Horseradish Cheese

Fresh horseradish root and creamy Jack from grass fed cows.

$ 10.29

Add to Cart

Muenster Cheese

Give your grilled cheese a makeover with this delicious Muenster from grass fed dairy cows!

$ 11.99

Add to Cart

Onion & Garlic Cheese

Take burgers up a notch with this cheese infused with farm fresh onions and garlic!

$ 9.59

Add to Cart

String Cheese

This Farm Country String Mozzerella is a tasty favorite for kids and adults alike!

$ 9.50

Add to Cart

Amish Butter Roll (2lbs.)

Natural, grass fed butter in a 2lb roll.

$ 14.95

Add to Cart

Pinconning Mild Cheddar Cheese

Pinconning cheddar from grass fed dairy cows.

$ 10.49

Add to Cart

Ground Chuck - Bulk 10 lb Bag

A juicy 80/20 blend of Grass Fed Ground Chuck makes the best burgers! You'll receive approximately 10 lbs of Ground Chuck in 1 large vacuum sealed bag.

$ 82.90

Add to Cart

Baby Swiss Cheese

Sweet buttery, nutty Baby Swiss from grass fed dairy cows.

$ 13.99

Add to Cart

Beef Bacon Cheese Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. You'll receive an approximately 1 lb package containing 4 quarter pound brats.

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Hickory Smoked Bacon - Thick Sliced

Thick Sliced and hickory smoked without the use of nitrates! Thick Sliced Hickory Smoked Bacon comes in a 1 lb package.

$ 10.99

Add to Cart

Italian Chicken Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. You'll receive an approximately 1 lb package containing 4 quarter pound brats.

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Chicken Chorizo Sausage, 1 lb

Spice up your breakfast with our Chicken Chorizo Breakfast Sausage!

$ 9.59

Add to Cart

Chicken, Bacon & Cheese Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. You'll receive an approximately 1 lb package containing 4 quarter pound brats.

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Chicken & Bacon Bratwurst

Each of our Quarter Pound Homemade Bratwurst is ground, stuffed and twisted by hand. You'll receive an approximately 1 lb package containing 4 quarter pound brats.

10% off $ 12.99 $ 11.69

Add to Cart

Pork Neck Bones

Add a boost of flavor to your soup or stew with our pasture raised Pork Neck Bones!

$ 4.49

Add to Cart

Ground Turkey, 1 lb

Our blend of Ground Turkey is made exclusively with the breast and thigh meat from our pastured turkeys and is available in 1 lb packages.

$ 9.99

Add to Cart

Chicken Andouille Sausage, 2/pk

Our Chicken Andouille Sausage is cured and blended with a mild mix of spices then smoked for just the right amount of flavor. Each package of chicken andouille sausage contains 2 - 10" smoked sausage links.

$ 9.74

Add to Cart

Salmon, 1 pc

Our Wild-Caught Alaskan Sockeye Salmon is pre-portioned into 6oz fillets and packaged frozen.

$ 7.87

Add to Cart

Shrimp, 1 lb

Our Wild-Caught Shrimp is caught off the Gulf of Mexico in US waters. You'll receive 1 lb of Wild-Caught Shrimp per package.

$ 12.99

Add to Cart

Healthy Start Bundle

Our Healthy Start Bundle includes a variety of our healthiest, leanest meat cuts. This bundle is great for beginners that are new to eating clean, or just want a fresh start with healthy choices. RECEIVE $5 OFF AND FREE BACON WHEN YOU ORDER TODAY!**

8% off $ 185.99 $ 170.99

Add to Cart

Snack Attack Add-On Pack

A variety of healthy jerky, snack sticks, and more!

13% off $ 51.99 $ 44.99

Add to Cart

Skirt Steak

This unique steak cut is super tender when marinated and sliced against the grain!

$ 18.99

Add to Cart

Jalapeno Cheese Burger Patties - 2/pk

WARNING: These 1/3 lb preformed square patties may be too spicy for the faint of heart! These are a must try for spicy lovers!

10% off $ 10.07 $ 9.06

Add to Cart

Jalapeno Cheese Sliders (6/pk)

These hot & spicy sliders cook up quick and are perfect for sharing! Our butcher slices them at a 1/4 inch thickness. You'll receive 6 pre-formed, round patties per package.

10% off $ 12.59 $ 11.33

Add to Cart

Bacon Burger Sliders (6/pk)

These delicious, smoky sliders cook up quick and are perfect for parties! Our butcher slices them at a 1/4 inch thickness. You'll receive 6 pre-formed, round patties per package.

10% off $ 12.49 $ 11.24

Add to Cart

Chicken Breakfast Patties, 6/pk

Try our popular Dairy Free Chicken Breakfast sausage now in pre-formed patties!! You'll receive 6 patties in a 1 lb package.

$ 9.99

Add to Cart

Pork Breakfast Patties, 6/pk

Our Dairy Free Pork Breakfast Sausage is now in pre-formed patties!! You'll receive 6 patties in a 1 lb package.

$ 9.69

Add to Cart

Half Turkey Breast, Boneless

Our Boneless, Skinless Pasture-Raised Turkey Breasts are scrumptious and moist! Each half-sized turkey breast averages about 2-3 lbs.

$ 23.98

Add to Cart

Turkey Cutlets

Our Boneless, Skinless Turkey Cutlets are scrumptious and moist! You'll receive 2 turkey cutlets per package.

$ 8.32

Add to Cart

Turkey Tenders

Our Turkey Tenders cut from our Pasture-Raised Turkey Breasts are scrumptious and moist! You'll receive approximately 1 lb of tenders per package.

$ 9.79

Add to Cart

Turkey Jerky

Our turkey tenders have been seasoned and dried for a tasty snack with no MSG!

$ 7.99

Add to Cart

Amish Butter Roll, (1lb.)

Natural, grass fed butter. Half roll, 1lb each.

$ 8.50

Add to Cart

Beef & Poultry Box

Join our Farm Share program and SAVE! Members save 5% on monthly deliveries of $100+. Our Beef & Poultry Box is the perfect way to join this amazing program.

$ 132.99

Add to Cart

Ground Sirloin Bundle, 25lb

Save an additional $5 when you buy 25lbs of Ground Sirloin! Your beef will arrive in complimentary 1lb packaging.

2% off $ 299.99 $ 294.99

Add to Cart

Turkey Drumstick

This fair favorite, hand-held meal tastes even better with John Henry's pasture-raised turkey. You'll receive 1 whole turkey drumstick per package.

$ 10.49

Add to Cart

Turkey Thigh, Boneless Skinless

This delicious cut of dark meat from our pasture-raised turkeys has been deboned, with the skin removed, and is ready for the grill!

$ 8.24

Add to Cart

Frozen T-Bone Bundle

Get 6 of your favorite grass-fed and finished T-Bone Steaks ready for the freezer!

6% off $ 167.99 $ 157.99

Add to Cart

Cheddar - Smoked

Natural, hardwood smoked cheddar cheese from Grass Fed dairy cows.

$ 12.69

Add to Cart

Subtotal

$ 0.00

Pinconning Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

What You're Getting

Helpful Hints & Cooking Tricks

Farming Practices

Related Products

Customers who bought this item also bought